How to Write a Horror Story: 14 Powerful Tips for Writing Horror

Jump To Section

Crafting an epic horror story is no small feat. It requires a delicate dance between fear, suspense, and emotion, leading your readers down a dark and twisted path. So how do you breathe life into nightmares that will haunt your audience long after they’ve turned the last page? Let’s unravel the secrets behind writing a truly terrifying horror story.

Understanding the Horror Genre

In the world of storytelling, horror is the spine-tingling genre that seeks to send shivers down your spine and make your heart race. These stories evoke fear, dread, and terror while delving into our darkest fears and anxieties. Horror often features a hearty helping of supernatural elements and terrifying, grotesque imagery to keep you up at night.

Horror Characters: Frankenstein Demon, Ghost, Werewolf, Vampire

Horror Subgenres

There’s a smorgasbord of flavors when it comes to horror, each with its own distinct characteristics.

  • Gothic: The dark and brooding cousin of horror, Gothic tales feature mysterious settings, supernatural elements, and an atmosphere that’ll make you feel like you’re wandering through a foggy graveyard at midnight.
  • Psychological: Mind-bending and bone-chilling, psychological horror dives deep into the internal struggles and mental instability of its characters, often leaving you questioning what’s real and what’s just a figment of a character’s twisted imagination.
  • Paranormal: Ghosts, spirits, and things that go bump in the night—paranormal horror deals with unexplained phenomena and otherworldly beings that defy the laws of nature.
  • Slasher: For fans of blood and gore, slasher horror follows a (usually) human antagonist who commits gruesome acts of violence, often wielding a weapon that becomes their terrifying trademark.
  • Body Horror: Skin-crawling body horror focuses on the grotesque transformation, mutilation, or degradation of the human body, often making you viscerally feel like your skeleton is trying to escape.
  • Survival Horror: It’s you against the world in survival horror, where characters are pitted against insurmountable odds in isolated or claustrophobic environments, struggling to stay alive in the face of relentless terror.
  • Sci-Fi Horror: When science fiction and horror collide, you get sci-fi horror, exploring the dark side of advanced technology and the consequences of scientific discoveries go terribly wrong.

Literary Genre Quiz (Easy)

4 Key Elements of Horror Stories

When it comes to cooking up a breathtaking horror story, there are a few essential ingredients that every writer should have in their pantry. These elements, when combined in just the right way, will leave your audience shivering with fear and eager for more. Let’s take a look at the key components that make a horror story truly terrifying.

4 Key Elements of Horror Stories: Fear, Suspense, Surprise, Disgust

1. Fear

The bread and butter of horror, fear is the primary ingredient that fuels the genre. A horror story aims to tap into our primal instincts and deep-rooted anxieties, leaving us trembling in our boots.

2. Suspense

Suspense is the secret sauce that keeps a horror story simmering. As the tension builds, the audience is kept on edge, wondering what lurks around the next corner, anticipating the next scare.

3. Surprise

A well-timed plot twist can be the cherry on top of a horror story. Unexpected turns heighten the fear and shock experienced by the audience, making the horror all the more impactful.

4. Disgust

Sometimes, horror stories need a little extra seasoning. Disgusting or grotesque imagery can intensify the audience’s feelings of unease and revulsion, creating an unforgettable experience that lingers long after the story has ended.

How To Write A Horror Story

Are you ready to delve into the dark corners of your imagination and unleash breathtaking tales? Fear not, brave writer—we’re here to guide you on your hair-raising journey. With these 14 powerful writing tips we’ll venture together into the realm of horror storytelling.

Manuscript pages, typewriter, skull and dagger on wooden table with torches in background

1. Know Your Audience

Before embarking on your horror journey, it’s crucial to gain a deep understanding of your target audience. By knowing who you’re writing for, you can better tailor your content and themes to appeal to their interests, making your story more engaging and effective. Here are some tips to help you get acquainted with your audience:

Read More Horror

Immerse yourself in the world of horror by reading a variety of horror stories, novels, and anthologies. This will help you gain insight into what works well in the genre, what resonates with readers, and the different types of horror stories, so you can figure out what you like and what’s popular among your target audience.

Identify Age & Preferences

Consider the age group and preferences of your target audience, as this will influence the content, tone, and level of gore or terror in your story. For example, a horror story for young adults might have different themes and intensity compared to a story aimed at more mature readers.

Study Your Readers’ Fears

Research the common fears and phobias among your target audience, and use this information to craft a story that will truly resonate with them. This could involve surveying readers, browsing online forums, or examining the most successful horror stories among your chosen demographic.

Analyze Trends & Subgenres

Keep an eye on current trends and popular subgenres within the horror category, as this can give you a better understanding of the types of stories your target audience is interested in. By exploring different subgenres, you can identify unique angles and themes that will make your story stand out.

Engage With the Horror Community

Interact with other horror enthusiasts, writers, and readers online and at events to gain valuable insights and feedback. This can help you fine-tune your understanding of your audience’s preferences and expectations, ultimately allowing you to create a story that truly connects with your readers.

2. Set Up a Fear Factor

Crafting an enthralling horror story requires you to establish a potent fear factor that will captivate and terrify your readers. This could be a supernatural force, a monstrous creature, or a human antagonist with sinister intentions. To make your fear factor truly compelling, consider drawing from your own personal fears and experiences. Here’s a brief overview of some fear types you can use to diversify your horror story:

  • Physical Harm & Violence: Tap into the primal fear of pain and injury, using vivid descriptions of harm and brutality to evoke unease and discomfort.
  • Loss of Mind & Insanity: Explore the terrifying prospect of losing one’s grip on reality as characters spiral into madness or face psychological torment.
  • Supernatural & Paranormal: Delve into the eerie world of ghosts, spirits, and unexplained phenomena, creating a disquieting, otherworldly atmosphere.
  • Monsters & Creatures: Unleash the nightmares of your imagination with horrifying beasts and creatures that defy nature, instilling fear through their menacing presence.
  • Fear of the Unknown: Exploit the unsettling nature of uncertainty, leaving your readers to fill in the blanks with their own imagination and amplifying their own personal fears.
  • Death & Mortality: Confront the inevitable and universal fear of death by exploring themes of loss, mortality, and the afterlife to evoke a sense of dread.

3. Vary the Types of Fear

To keep your readers glued to your spine-tingling tale, it’s essential to incorporate a variety of fear types. Mixing different sources of terror can prevent your story from becoming predictable and maintain suspense throughout.

4. Build an Emotional Core

A good horror story goes beyond mere frights and scares. To make your story truly memorable, create an emotional core that resonates with your readers. This could be a character’s internal struggle, a tragic backstory, or a love story intertwined with the horror. By giving your readers something to connect with, you’ll make your story more impactful and enduring.

5. Use Setting and Atmosphere

Setting and atmosphere play a crucial role in creating a sense of dread and unease. Choose a location that lets your chosen fears flourish, such as an abandoned house, a haunted forest, or a desolate town. Use vivid descriptions to build an atmosphere that keeps your readers on edge, and make the setting a character in its own right.

6. Exploit the Unknown and Inexplicable

One of the most effective ways to instill fear in your readers is by tapping into the fear of the unknown. Incorporate mysterious elements, unexplained events, and enigmatic characters to create a sense of uncertainty and disquiet. This will keep your readers guessing and heighten their sense of unease.

7. Increase Vulnerability Through Isolation

Isolation can make your characters more vulnerable, making your story that much more frightening. Separate your characters from the safety of others, either physically or emotionally. This could involve stranding them in a remote location, cutting off communication, or creating rifts between characters that leave them feeling alone and exposed.

8. Suspense and Pacing

Mastering suspense and pacing is key to writing a successful horror story. Build tension gradually, interspersing moments of calm with sudden shocks and scares. Use cliffhangers, false alarms, and unexpected twists to keep your readers on the edge of their seats.

9. Add Sensory Details

In order to truly immerse your readers in the spine-chilling world of your horror story, it’s important to include vivid sensory details that appeal to all five senses. By painting a rich, multisensory picture, you can heighten the sense of dread and unease, making your story all the more terrifying.


Use descriptive language to create clear, evocative visuals. This could involve the ghastly appearance of a ghost, the eerie flickering of lights in a haunted house, or the sinister shadows that seem to have a life of their own.

Example: The moonlight cast elongated shadows across the desolate room, as the wallpaper peeled away like dead skin, revealing the rotting wooden walls beneath.


Use onomatopoeia and other auditory descriptors to create an unsettling atmosphere. Consider the creaking of floorboards, the howling of wind, or the distant, haunting laughter of a sinister presence.

Example: The deafening silence was suddenly pierced by the shrill screech of rusty hinges, as the long-abandoned door creaked open, ever so slowly.


Describe the tactile sensations your characters experience to further immerse your readers in their horrifying experiences. This might include the clammy touch of a ghostly hand, the suffocating grip of fear, or the icy chill of a draft in an otherwise sealed room.

Example: Her heart raced as she felt the cold, damp breath of something unseen on the back of her neck, sending shivers down her spine.


Incorporate taste to enhance the sense of unease and discomfort in your story. This could involve the metallic taste of fear-induced adrenaline, the stale taste of an old, musty room, or the acrid taste of poison in the air.

Example: As he entered the decrepit mansion, the taste of mold and decay filled his mouth, leaving a bitter, lingering aftertaste that refused to fade.


Use evocative scents to establish an atmosphere of dread or unease. This might include the putrid odor of decay, the sulfurous stench of demonic activity, or the sickly-sweet aroma of a mysterious, sinister perfume.

Example: The room was suffused with the cloying, rancid smell of decay, a miasma of death and desolation that clung to every surface like an invisible shroud.

10. Create Dynamic Characters

Strong, believable characters are essential for any good story, and horror is no exception. Create well-rounded, dynamic characters with their own motivations, fears, and desires. Make sure that your readers will care about your characters, so they’re truly scared for them as the stakes become clear.

11. Make the Stakes Obvious

Following form the previous point, ensure that the stakes are high and the consequences of failure are clear. Whether it’s a character’s life, sanity, or relationships at stake, make sure your readers understand what’s on the line. This will keep them emotionally invested in your story and heighten the tension.

12. Subvert Expectations

To keep your horror story fresh and surprising, consider subverting your readers’ expectations. Play with horror tropes and conventions, turning them on their head to catch your audience off guard. This can make your story more unpredictable and exciting, helping it stand out from the crowd.

13. Find a Unique Premise

A unique premise is key to crafting a memorable horror story. Rather than rehashing tired clichés, look for a new angle or twist to set your story apart. Think about what scares you personally, and explore those fears in your writing. This will give your story a genuine, authentic quality that readers will appreciate.

14. Ground Your Story in Realism

While horror often involves supernatural or fantastical elements, grounding your story in realism can make it more relatable and therefore scarier. Develop a believable world and characters, and use realistic dialogue and relationships. This will help your readers suspend their disbelief and become fully immersed in the horror you’ve created.

7 Common Mistakes in Horror

Even the most seasoned horror writers can get caught in common pitfalls that can weaken the impact of their terrifying tales. By identifying and avoiding these mistakes, you can create a chilling and engaging story that keeps your readers hooked. Here are some common horror mistakes and how to avoid them.

Horror clown with a knife slipping on a banana slice in an abandoned house

1. Revealing Too Much Too Soon

One key element of a successful horror story is maintaining suspense and tension. Revealing too much information too soon can undermine these feelings and leave your readers disengaged.

How to avoid it: Use a gradual, layered approach when disclosing information, and be strategic with your pacing. Focus on building anticipation and suspense by slowly unveiling the fear factor, the characters’ backstories, and the story’s mysteries.

2. Overusing Clichés & Stereotypes

Too many familiar tropes played straight can make your horror story feel unoriginal and predictable. Relying on clichés and stereotypes can weaken the story’s impact and leave your readers unimpressed.

How to avoid it: Experiment with new ideas and subvert expectations by putting your unique twist on classic horror elements. Explore different genres and story structures to create a fresh and engaging horror experience.

3. Relying Solely on Gore and Violence

Excessive gore and violence can desensitize your readers and detract from the overall horror experience.

How to avoid it: Focus on building tension and fear through psychological and atmospheric elements. Make use of the unknown, the supernatural, and the psychological to create a multi-layered, chilling experience that goes beyond mere gore.

4. Forcing Jump Scares or Shock Value

Jump scares and shock value can quickly lose their effectiveness if overused or forced. They can also detract from the story’s overall atmosphere and pacing.

How to avoid it: Use jump scares and shocking moments sparingly and purposefully. Allow the suspense and tension to build naturally before delivering a well-timed, genuinely surprising moment to maintain their strong effect.

5. Unbelievable Character Actions

Characters who behave unrealistically or make illogical decisions can frustrate readers and hinder their ability to connect with the story.

How to avoid it: Develop well-rounded characters who act and react believably within the story’s context. Ensure that their motivations and actions are grounded in their personalities and circumstances.

6. Weak or Unrealistic Dialogue

Inauthentic or poorly written dialogue can break immersion and detract from the story’s overall impact.

How to avoid it: Focus on crafting natural, engaging dialogue that reveals character and advances the plot. Be mindful of each character’s unique voice and speech patterns so that their dialogue remains consistent throughout the story.

7. Lack of a Clear Resolution

A satisfying resolution is essential for any story, including and maybe especially horror. A lack of closure or a weak resolution can leave readers feeling unsatisfied and disconnected from the story.

How to avoid it: Plan your story’s resolution from the beginning, ensuring that it ties up loose ends and provides a satisfying conclusion. Whether your ending is tragic, triumphant, or ambiguous, make sure it’s emotionally resonant and provides closure for your readers.

9 Great Examples of Horror Stories

Whether you’re new to the genre or a seasoned horror aficionado, it’s always helpful to study successful horror stories to learn what makes them work. These stories have stood the test of time, captivating and terrifying readers for generations. Here are some notable examples of classic, modern, and short horror stories to inspire you.

Classic Horror Stories

  • The Tell-Tale Heart by Edgar Allan Poe: This macabre tale of guilt and madness explores the psyche of a murderer who can’t escape the incessant beating of his victim’s heart beneath the floorboards.
  • The Shining by Stephen King: Set in the isolated Overlook Hotel, this chilling novel delves into the supernatural and psychological horrors that unfold as a family descends into madness.
  • Frankenstein by Mary Shelley: This groundbreaking Gothic novel tells the tragic tale of Dr. Victor Frankenstein and his monstrous creation, exploring themes of ambition, isolation, and responsibility.

Modern Horror Stories

  • The Haunting of Hill House by Shirley Jackson: A chilling, atmospheric tale of a group of people who are invited to spend a week in a mysterious and possibly haunted mansion, where they must confront their own inner demons.
  • Bird Box by Josh Malerman: In this suspenseful and terrifying post-apocalyptic novel, a woman and her two children navigate a world filled with unseen horrors that drive people to madness and death.
  • Mexican Gothic by Silvia Moreno-Garcia: This eerie, Gothic tale set in 1950s Mexico follows a young woman as she unravels the dark secrets and supernatural occurrences in her cousin’s new home.

Horror Short Stories

  • The Monkey’s Paw by W.W. Jacobs: This classic horror short story centers around a cursed monkey’s paw that grants its owner three wishes, with horrifying consequences.
  • The Lottery by Shirley Jackson: This unsettling tale explores the dark side of human nature and the power of tradition as a small town carries out a brutal and shocking annual ritual.
  • Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been? by Joyce Carol Oates: Inspired by a true crime story, this chilling narrative follows a teenage girl who becomes the target of a sinister, supernatural figure.

By immersing yourself in these great horror stories, you can better understand the genre’s conventions, learn from successful authors’ techniques, and ultimately improve your own horror writing.

Literary Genre Quiz (Hard)

Frequently Asked Questions

Finally, let’s examine some frequently asked questions related to writing horror stories.

How Do You Start a Horror Story?

Starting a horror story often involves creating a strong opening that hooks the reader and sets the tone. You can begin by introducing an unsettling atmosphere, a mysterious situation, or an intriguing character. No matter how you begin, you want to start building tension and anticipation from the outset.

What Makes a Story Scary?

A story becomes scary by exploiting human fears and anxieties, whether they be physical, psychological, or emotional. This can be achieved through elements such as suspense, pacing, atmosphere, and the unknown. A strong emotional core, engaging characters, and high stakes also contribute to a story’s scariness.

What Are Some Scary Story Ideas?

Scary story ideas can emerge from various sources, including personal experiences, urban legends, and historical events. Examples include haunted locations, cursed objects, supernatural creatures, or psychological horrors. The key here is finding a unique premise that resonates with your audience’s fears and brings a fresh perspective to the genre.

Should a Horror Story Be in First Person?

Writing a horror story in first person allows the reader to experience the protagonist’s fear and emotions directly. However, other points of view can also be effective, such as third-person limited or omniscient, depending on the story’s structure and intended effect. Ultimately, the choice of POV should serve the story’s purpose and enhance the reader’s experience.

What Age Group Likes Horror?

Horror stories can appeal to various age groups, from young adults to mature readers. The key is to tailor your story’s content, themes, and complexity to your target audience. For example, young adult horror may focus on coming-of-age themes and relatable characters, while adult horror may delve into deeper psychological and existential fears.

Is Horror Hard to Write?

Writing horror can be challenging, as it requires a delicate balance of suspense, pacing, and emotional resonance. It also demands creativity when crafting unique and terrifying scenarios. However, with practice and a strong understanding of the genre’s conventions, you can write a horror story that effectively captivates and terrifies your readers.

Want to sell more Books?

Get a Proven Step-by-step Blueprint to Launch Your Book Successfully